Water Heater Breaker is Tripping: Do I Need an Electrician or a Plumber?

Do I Need an Electrician or a Plumber When the Breaker to My Water Heater Is Tripping?

When the breaker to your water heater trips, it can be a perplexing and frustrating situation.  Your immediate concern is likely to get your hot water back on, but the question that arises is: Do you need an electrician or a plumber to fix the issue?  Both professionals play crucial roles in water heater repairs and installations, but their responsibilities differ significantly.  Understanding these roles can help you make an informed decision and resolve the problem efficiently.

Jump Ahead:

water heater breaker tripping

The Role of Electricians in Water Heater Issues

Electricians are specialized in handling electrical systems, which include the wiring and components of your water heater.  Here’s how an electrician can help:

1. Diagnosing Electrical Problems

When your breaker trips, it’s often a sign of an electrical issue.  An electrician can diagnose problems such as:

  • Faulty Wiring: Over time, the wiring to your water heater may degrade or become damaged.  An electrician can inspect the wiring for wear and tear, ensuring it’s in good condition and capable of carrying the electrical load.
  • Overloaded Circuit: If your water heater shares a circuit with other high-demand appliances, it could overload and trip the breaker.  An electrician can assess your electrical system to ensure each appliance has its dedicated circuit if necessary.
  • Short Circuits: A short circuit occurs when electrical current travels along an unintended path, often due to exposed wires or internal faults.  This can cause the breaker to trip as a safety measure. An electrician can locate and repair short circuits to prevent future issues.
  • Faulty Breaker: Sometimes, the breaker itself may be faulty.  An electrician can test and replace the breaker if needed, ensuring it functions correctly.

2. Installing Electrical Components

Electricians are also essential when installing new electrical components for your water heater.  This includes:

  • Heating Elements: If your water heater’s heating elements are faulty, an electrician or plumber can replace them.  These elements are crucial for heating the water, and improper installation can lead to further issues.
  • Thermostats: The thermostat controls the water temperature.  If it’s malfunctioning, an electrician or plumber can replace or repair it to ensure your water heater operates efficiently.
  • Wiring Upgrades: For older homes, the electrical system may not meet current standards.  An electrician can upgrade the wiring to ensure it’s safe and capable of supporting modern appliances.

Back to Top

The Role of Plumbers in Water Heater Issues

Plumbers, on the other hand, specialize in the plumbing aspects of your water heater.  Here’s how a plumber can assist:

1. Diagnosing Plumbing Problems

If the issue with your water heater isn’t electrical, a plumber can diagnose potential plumbing problems such as:

  • Water Leaks: Leaks can occur in various parts of your water heater, including the tank, valves, and connections.  A plumber can locate and fix these leaks to prevent water damage and ensure your heater operates efficiently.
  • Sediment Build-Up: Over time, sediment can accumulate in the tank, affecting the water heater’s efficiency and potentially causing it to overheat and trip the breaker.  A plumber can flush the tank to remove sediment and improve performance.
  • Pressure Relief Valve Issues: The pressure relief valve prevents excessive pressure buildup in the tank.  If it’s faulty, it can cause leaks or other issues.  A licensed plumber can inspect and replace the valve if necessary.
  • Tank Corrosion: If the tank itself is corroded, it may need to be replaced.  A plumber can assess the condition of the tank and recommend the best course of action.  You should schedule a plumber sooner rather than later before a corroded tank turns into a disastrous leak.

2. Installing Plumbing Components

Plumbers are also essential for installing and maintaining the plumbing components of your water heater.  This includes:

  • Anode Rod Replacement: The anode rod prevents tank corrosion.  If it’s worn out, a plumber can replace it to extend the life of your water heater.
  • Expansion Tank Installation: An expansion tank absorbs excess pressure caused by thermal expansion. If your system doesn’t have one, a plumber can install it to prevent pressure-related issues.
  • Pipe Insulation: Insulating the pipes connected to your water heater can improve efficiency and prevent heat loss. A plumber can install insulation to help maintain water temperature and reduce energy costs.

Back to Top

When to Call an Electrician

Here are specific scenarios where calling an electrician is the best course of action:

  1. Breaker Keeps Tripping: If your breaker consistently trips when the water heater is in use, it’s likely an electrical issue.
  2. No Power to the Water Heater: If there’s no power reaching the water heater, an electrician can trace and fix the problem.
  3. Burnt Smell or Scorch Marks: These are signs of electrical faults that need immediate attention from an electrician.
  4. New Water Heater Installation: If you’re installing a new electric water heater, an electrician should handle the wiring to ensure it’s done safely and correctly.
  5. Buzzing or Humming from the Breaker Box: Electrical panels are not meant to make noise.  If your breaker box is buzzing or humming, contact an electrician immediately.  You may require a repair or an electrical panel replacement.

Back to Top

When to Call a Plumber

Consider calling a plumber in the following situations:

  1. Water Leaks: Any visible water leaks from the heater or connected pipes require a plumber’s expertise.
  2. Low Hot Water Pressure: If the hot water pressure is low, it might be due to a plumbing issue that a plumber can diagnose and fix.
  3. Strange Noises: Rumbling or popping sounds from the water heater can indicate sediment build-up, which a plumber can address.  This problem may require flushing the water heater to resolve.
  4. Water Heater Replacement: If you need to replace the entire unit, a plumber should handle the plumbing connections and ensure the system is set up correctly.  You should not try to install your water heater on your own.

Back to Top

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, whether you need an electrician or a plumber when the breaker to your water heater is tripping depends on the nature of the problem.  Electricians handle the electrical aspects, diagnosing and repairing wiring, breakers, and heating elements.  Plumbers address plumbing issues, including leaks, sediment build-up, and pressure problems.  By understanding the roles of each professional, you can make an informed decision and ensure your water heater is repaired or installed correctly, providing you with reliable hot water and peace of mind.  If you’re still unsure, contacting a professional service like Surfside Services can help guide you to the right solution for your specific situation.

Back to Top

Choose a Plumbing & Electrical Company

As a plumbing and electrical company, it helps keep things simple when you're unsure which service you need.  Our technicians are trained to recognize when they need to request support from another department to make sure we provide the best service possible to our customers.